Saturday, 31 March 2012

Who am I?

Firstly, when I say "who am I?" in the title of this post, I do not mean it in a philosophical way. I just mean that this post is a way of me to share what events have happened in my life that I feel have led me to this project. I really hope that I will answer the "who am I?" question in more philosophical detail a little bit by doing this crazy project, but I'm trying not to expect it.

This project is very close to my heart. And to who I believe I will be one day.

I just wanted to give this project as honest and comprehensive an introduction as I could muster so that you, my hopeful potential readers, have a decent understanding of where I'm coming from.

To start with, my father was raised Jewish and my mother Christian. My whole life I've been "half-Jewish" (whatever that actually means) or Christian or Jewish or somewhere in the middle. I know little about either of these religions, at least from my parents. I did attend a Lutheran church for about five years when I was a teenager, so I have a decent understanding of Christianity from that point of view, but Judaism is far more difficult to learn in a way that you can really understand it, from my point of view. Really, it's not that difficult to walk into a church and get what I always viewed as the main thing to know about Christianity. Accept Jesus Christ as your Saviour and you are saved; you are a Christian. The rest is really details, as far as my understanding ever was (although attending other, more traditional churches may give a different understanding, I might think). Judaism, especially as a religion (less so with the cultural aspects, I find) is much more complicated: there is always so much more to learn. I feel like these details, when summed up, give more of an idea of what religious Judaism is about. I don't mean this as a compliment or a sick burn to either; it's no better, no worse, just different (like a nominal variable, for those of you who took Social Statistics with Dr. Linda Henderson).

Anyways, that is all to say that I don't understand much about religious Judaism. I separate this, in my mind, from the cultural aspects of Judaism because I am a cultural Jew. My mother, even, is a cultural Jew. This is far harder to explain, but easier for me to understand. Also something I will address a little later in this introduction.

So, back to religious Judaism - I have had little experience in synagogues, only having gone to actual religious services three or four times for High Holidays (Rosh Hashanah/Yom Kippur - the Jewish New Year and the Day of Atonement), and never understood much of what was going on. Essentially, my synagogue experience is not eating for a day for reasons I do not really understand and trying to follow along as best I could with the Hebrew (there is always an English translation, but that doesn't make you any less lost), standing up when other people stood up, sitting down when other people sat down.... I'm sure you get the picture.

Anyways, I have a Bachelor of Arts degree in Sociology, and in my third year I started to become interested in the sociological study of Canadian Jews because of some papers I wrote for a couple courses, namely on Diasporic and Transnational communities in Canada. Some background - the word "diasporic" or "diaspora", for those of you who do not already know, refers to an ethnic community that is spread all over the world, or at least away from their "homeland" (I use the word homeland in quotation marks because in some cases, like with Jews before 1948, the homeland that is referred to - Israel in the Jews' case - may not exist politically). In any case, Jews are the original example of a diaspora and since then most ethnic communities also have diasporic elements as well.

Part of my journey here has included a great deal of reading about Jews and as many assignments as I could make about Jews in Canada. Through all of this, I started to realize a constant name in the authors' lines of most of the articles I was reading. Dr. Morton Weinfeld is a professor at McGill University and studies North American Jews as his research interest. One very important book to me, written by Dr. Weinfeld, is Like Everyone But Different: The paradoxical success of Canadian Jews. This wonderful book has quite literally changed my life. I would recommend it to anyone on earth, but especially Jewish Canadians. Another book that led me here is called Stars of David, and it is written by Abigail Pogrebin. I'll spare you the reading list, but I just really need to share those two, because it is really where I came to this whole thing from. I will hopefully mention many more along the way of this project, but I would highly recommend those two as a starting point if you're wanting to get inside my head a little.

In the interests of keeping this post a near reasonable length, I will also quickly mention that I live in Calgary, Alberta. Calgary has a fairly small Jewish community. Both of my parents are from Winnipeg, Manitoba (which has the third largest Jewish community in Canada), where we spent a lot of time while I was growing up. That is where my Jewish roots are.

I would be extremely happy to answer any questions you might have about me or this project or really anything, so just comment and let me know.

Thanks so much for stopping by; I hope you take a look through my posts in the future as well.

Next up: what is the project then?

Cheers, L'Chaim,

-L.

4 comments:

  1. I understand your reference to a "cultural Jew". In certain situations with the traditional Jewish community I have had discrepancies in how and if I am considered a Jew, being born to a Catholic mother and Jewish father, with no emphasis on religion and no bar mitzvah. I similarly refer to myself as a "cultural Jew". In layman's terms being a cultural Jew is about interacting with and being a part of a Jewish culture. I say "a" Jewish culture in that since the Jewish people have truly become diasporic, the concept of North-American Judiasm (which I have experienced growing up in Canada) differs from cultural Judiasm in other places.

    As many experiences as a "cultural North-American Jew" I get Seinfeld references. I really enjoy corned beef on rye. I knew what a latke was before I'd ever heard of hash browns.

    The exciting thing about cultural Judiasm (as the concept that I am describing) is that it transcends religion. I personally find value in this because it creates an inclusive community as opposed to an exclusive. You don't have to have a bar mitzvah, you don't even have to have Jewish relatives. Even a good friend of mine was dubbed an "honourary Jew" by some Jewish friends of his because he was exposed to these cultures and traditions. In many ways my Catholic mother exemplified a role model as a cuturally Jewish mother simply from her exposure to that world (especially in cuisine.. I can taste it even now!).

    I wish you luck on your ambitious goals in this project! I'm off to search for the recipe for a good kugel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the excellent comments! I love how much of Jewish identity is food based (I realize that Jews don't have a monopoly on this, but it's so central, especially in the cultural rather than religious sense). Especially the corned beef on rye. Did you know that some people put cheese on corned beef sandwiches? Ick. I have always felt that my aversion to that particular practice is a bit of Jewish identity embedded in my stomach, ha ha.

      I like how your mom was a culturally Jewish mother even though she didn't convert. My mom has also been the driving force between the occasional Hanukkah candle lighting or latke making evening rather than my dad.

      Thanks again for your comment - see you again soon! And let me know if you come up with a good kugel recipe! :)

      Delete
  2. Hi Lauren. I know your father and I have never met your mother but I too an half Jewish but it is my mother that was Jewish. I am old and crotchety and a red neck and proud of all of it. This is what I have learned from religion. All religion is inherently evil and this is why. GOD GAVE US THE TRUTH AND THE DEVIL SAID HE WOULD ORGANIZE IT FOR US INTO RELIGION. I wish I had something profound and positive for you to grasp but all I have I just shared with you. I hope you are over 18 so your family cannot be mad at me and your father will clarify who and what I am.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First of all, thanks for your comment. I guess what I would really like to say is that the spirit of this project is to not take things at face value. I don't mean to go through the mitzvot, take each one as it is and turn into an Orthodox Jew or anything. What I'm aiming for is to find out more about each of the commandments and see what they mean to me. I mean, sometimes ancient wisdom is ancient and wise for a reason. Other times, it's totally outdated. Or at least that's what I think I will find out through this project.

      So I hope that helps explain why I'm hesitant to take what you say at face value, just like I'm hesitant to take religion at face value in general.

      And please, for you and anyone else, don't hold your comments back because you think they aren't welcome. Specifically if you think they aren't welcome by my family. I can certainly take care of myself, and this is meant to be an open forum for whatever ideas are sparked by this project.

      Thanks again

      Delete

What do you think? Let's start some discussion!